On Valentine's Day, Joy Kalekye says she received a worried call from a friend. Her friend instructed her to check social media, where a video clip of her had been uploaded.
The video depicts the student, then a teenager, standing alone near a busy road in Kenya's capital, checking her phone. The person filming walks towards her and states, "Hello, I like how you look."
This was an interaction Kalekye had completely forgotten about.
"I realised, oh, it's this man from Russia that I met last year," she explained. After watching the video, she understood he had been filming her without consent.
Kalekye appears in one of several videos posted online that capture a man approaching women in Kenya and Ghana who do not appear to know they are being recorded.
He reaches for their hair, takes their hands, asks for their phone number, and asks to meet up later.
These women are targets of a widespread phenomenon where men use covert recording devices to film interactions without permission and share the videos online, sometimes amassing millions of views.
Some individuals behind these videos earn money by uploading them on digital networks, or profit by marketing tutorials that purport to assist men interact with women.
There has been widespread condemnation among activists and politicians in both Kenya and Ghana, who are demanding the arrest of the man, who claims in the videos he is from Russia.
But online, the women have also been blamed, ridiculed, and subjected to abuse.
"It feels like becoming a celebrity, but not in a positive manner," states Kalekye.
This public reaction, according to Brenda Yambo, a lawyer at a legal federation in Kenya, reinforces damaging gender stereotypes and unfairly places responsibility onto the victims.
Instead of focusing on the unlawful act—the unauthorized filming and sharing of the clips—the public examines the woman's behavior, she explains.
"Commentary focuses on her choices, her character, her attire," she says, explaining that this increases the harm caused and discourages victims from reporting the incidents.
The Viral Spread and Secondary Harm
After the man approached her in March last year, the student turned down his offer to meet up.
However, it was only this year that her video and others gained massive traction online. Local social media accounts re-uploaded the clips, some with provocative captions in local languages in an apparent effort to attract viewers to their profiles.
A 22-year-old, who is presently without a job and describes he is trying to build an online presence as a digital creator in Nairobi, recalls finding the videos on a Russian YouTube channel.
He remembers posting one of the videos to his own social media account one Sunday, just before going to church. Then he turned off his phone.
"I thought it was acceptable to post the videos because people were looking for them and I had downloaded them," he explained.
Within a short time, he claims it received about a vast number of views and numerous remarks.
After he and other users had shared the video of Kalekye, as she was walking outside her house, she reports a man shouted "a derogatory phrase in Swahili". This suggests she needs to take anti-retroviral medication.
"He said: 'You're going to die.' It was so devastating. And then he was yelling, people are looking at me," she says.
The content creator says he removed the woman's video after she left a comment underneath it and also removed another woman's video upon request. He stated that it was not acceptable "exposing them like that" with the videos spreading widely.
Despite this, two other videos of women filmed without their consent remain on his channel.
He said he did not believe there was a necessity to delete them because no-one had complained and the videos did not attract as much engagement.
Legal Responses and Finding the Filmer
As additional online profiles reuploaded the videos, Kenya's Directorate of Criminal Investigations (DCI) released a warning, stating that resharing the non-consensual videos amounts to secondary victimisation and could lead to criminal prosecution.
Officials in Ghana named the man behind filming the videos as a foreign national, released his passport photo, and stated they want to bring him back to Ghana to face charges under their digital legislation. They allege he filmed personal interactions without consent and profited from the material online. His whereabouts are unknown.
Not one recording reviewed reveal the man's face, making it hard to tell if Liulkov is the one who approached Kalekye.
Several recordings were geolocated to shopping centers in Nairobi and Mombasa. In Ghana, some women were contacted near a major mall in the capital, Accra.
The voice in all these videos is consistent, and while his face is not seen, his arm is shown wearing what appears to be a distinctive timepiece.
In some clips, both hands are visibly unoccupied, implying he is not holding a camera.
A woman in Ghana, who asked to not be named, told that she was contacted in January but rejected the offer to go with him.
She is not aware of any video of her meeting online but believes it was the same man in the widely shared clips.
"It's upsetting seeing those images. It gives me unpleasant memories. That could have been me," she states.
Accounts on a foreign social platform were found with photographs resembling Liulkov, including one where the man is wearing a timepiece nearly identical to the one seen in the videos.
There is also a picture, posted in recently, of him wearing what appears to be camera-equipped eyewear and a local headwear. He is photographed outside a mosque in a Kenyan town.
Russian media stated that the videos were posted by channels using a pseudonym combining words for male genitals and glory in Russian.
A website under this name, now removed, allegedly sold a custom tutorial to approaching women for a small fee.
Compilations of similar style videos have circulated with this handle as a logo, including some that appear to be from other parts of the world, like Cuba.
Contacted by media, Liulkov stated he was not behind any of the referenced social media handles or websites and refuted claims of approached women in Kenya, Ghana, or Cuba using recording eyewear.
To another media outlet, he admitted having met women in Kenya and Ghana but denied having filmed them.
Digital Harassment and a Plea for Empathy
A large amount of the internet discourse centered on the behavior of the affected women, mocking them and using misogynistic slurs, arguing they were not victims at all.
The young woman says she is talking about her ordeal publicly to challenge what has been said about her.
She admits she considered isolating herself but thought: "I'm strong. I don't have to hide because of just something someone said."
She believes the negative reaction was self-righteous because the recordings captured an everyday occurrence and urges people should stop judging.
"People underestimate how that small negative comment, that you can type without thinking, can affect someone's life."